Language
The Weight of a Word How Legal Language Learned to Say Exactly What It Means
Inside the centuries-long struggle to write sentences that can't be misread, and why even a single comma can cost millions.
Listen to the opening
0:002:39
In this episode
- A Sentence Worth Five Million Dollars
- The Doubled Words
- Why Exactness Is Expensive
- Casting a Legal Spell
- The Plain Language Rebellion
- Counting Words Instead of Guessing
- What a Word Weighs
The opening
The sentence that cost a Maine dairy company five million dollars is short enough to read in a single breath. It is part of a state overtime law, and it lists the kinds of work that do not earn extra pay after forty hours. The exempt activities are canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, and then a final phrase: packing for shipment or distribution of agricultural produce, meat and fish products, and perishable foods.
Look at that last phrase. Between the word "shipment" and the word "or" there is no comma. Everything turned on that gap.
The people affected were delivery drivers for Oakhurst Dairy. They picked up milk and other products and carried them to stores and warehouses. The drivers said they had been working overtime without being paid for it. The company said the law exempted them, because the exemption covered "distribution," and distributing dairy is exactly what drivers do.
The drivers read the sentence another way. With no comma after "shipment," the phrase "packing for shipment or distribution" can be understood as a single activity: packing for the purpose of shipment, or packing for the purpose of distribution. Under that reading, the exemption covers the people who box up the goods. It does not cover the people who drive them. If the legislature had put a comma after "shipment," then "distribution" would stand on its own as a separate exempt activity, and the drivers would be out of luck.
The case reached the federal appeals court in Boston, and the judges began their opinion with a line that has since been quoted in law schools and newsrooms: for want of a comma, we have this case. The court found the sentence genuinely ambiguous. It noted that Maine's own legislative drafting guidance discourages the serial comma, the comma before the final item in a list, which is the very tool that would have settled the question. Because the overtime statute exists to protect workers, the court reasoned, ambiguous exemptions should be read narrowly. The drivers won the right to press their claim. The following year, the company and the drivers settled for five million dollars.
Most of us treat punctuation as seasoning. This case shows it can be structure. And it raises a question that sits underneath all of legal writing. Why do lawyers write the way they do, with all the repetition, the odd phrases, and the sentences that seem to circle back on themselves? A good part of the answer is that legal writing is a long record of arguments like this one. Each strange phrase tends to be a scar from some earlier fight over what words meant.
The episode continues in the Compound app.